Barebones explanations not nearly enough to justify billions in transmission cost overruns, OPC tells PJM Board
BALTIMORE – The minimal public information that PJM has shared to support its authorization of billions of dollars in cost increases for regionally planned transmission projects is wholly inadequate to protect customers from bearing unnecessary costs, the Office of People’s Counsel said in a letter sent today to the Board of Managers of the regional transmission organization PJM Interconnection, LLC. OPC’s letter asks the Board to reconsider its decision this week to authorize the cost increases.
“Transmission costs are a major contributor to escalating utility bills, but they undergo very little scrutiny at PJM and benefit from a presumption of reasonableness before federal regulators,” Maryland People’s Counsel David S. Lapp said. “PJM must step up its oversight of these massive cost increases, and its decisions should be far more transparent than what has just transpired.”
OPC’s letter focused on two recent disclosures by transmission developers of massive cost increases to previously approved projects. The developers of the Valley Link project that runs through West Virginia to a substation near Frederick, Maryland, reported increases in estimated capital expenditures in excess of $2 billion—a 73 percent increase—and a two-year delay of the initial in-service date. The increase is supported by a single-page explanation containing only barebones justifications provided to the public through PJM’s stakeholder process, OPC’s letter explains.
Separately, Exelon reported an 86 percent increase of $783 million in capital expenditure for three projects compared to its initial estimates, also supported only by a single-page explanation. A substantial portion of the Exelon cost increases are for projects Exelon’s subsidiaries, Baltimore Gas and Electric and Potomac Electric Power Company, are constructing in Maryland.
Maryland customers pay substantially for such regional projects—even for portions not located in Maryland—under PJM’s method of assigning costs for these projects. Unlike many transmission projects in PJM that are not subject to competition and undergo little review, PJM selected these large regional projects through a competitive procurement based on substantially lower-cost proposals.
OPC’s letter questions whether PJM has complied with the requirements of PJM’s manual, which requires “re-analysis” when “significant cost increases” occur to determine whether “a more economical solution is better suited to solve the issue.” The letter notes OPC’s inability to find anywhere in the public record whether PJM performed the required analysis.
“The minimal disclosure PJM demands of transmission companies for massive cost increases raises serious questions about the rigor and depth of the transmission companies’ and PJM’s management and oversight practices,” Lapp said. “The size of these increases raises questions about the validity of PJM’s initial selection of projects and the benefits customers should receive from the competitive procurement of large regional projects.”
OPC has raised similar concerns about cost increases with respect to several of Exelon’s transmission projects in Maryland, the cost of which will be borne almost entirely by Maryland customers. BGE’s planned projects on the Baltimore Peninsula have increased from an initial budgeted capital expenditure of $105 million to more than $500 million, and BGE more than doubled its initial costs for the transmission projects related to the eventual retirement of the Brandon Shores power plant, from less than $740 million (after a reduction from $780 million) to over $1.5 billion, less than two years from when it submitted its initial costs.
OPC’s report released earlier this year projected that Maryland customers will pay $5.4 billion for transmission projects over just five years, from 2031 to 2035—three times the yearly average of the previous 20 years, from 2010-2030. OPC’s report did not account for the Valley Link or Exelon cost increases, a share of which will be allocated to Maryland. Because many transmission costs are not reflected in customer rates until the projects are in service, many of the costs for the Valley Link and Exelon projects will not be seen in customer bills until after 2030.
For more on OPC’s advocacy on transmission costs, visit OPC’s website.
The Maryland Office of People’s Counsel is an independent state agency that represents Maryland’s residential consumers in electric, natural gas, telecommunications, private water and certain transportation matters before the Public Service Commission, federal regulatory agencies, and the courts.
* * *
|