State consumer advocates call on PJM Board to delay upcoming capacity market auction
BALTIMORE – PJM Interconnection (PJM), the regional transmission organization that serves Maryland, should postpone the upcoming December capacity market auction because it could impose billions of dollars in data center-driven capacity costs on PJM’s 67 million consumers, the Maryland Office of People’s Counsel (OPC) told the PJM Board of Managers in a letter submitted jointly today with other state consumer advocates.
The consumer advocates’ letter cites an analysis of PJM’s Independent Market Monitor (IMM) warning that the auction could impose an additional $5-$10 billion in data center-related capacity costs on consumers. The letter aligns with the IMM’s recommendation that PJM postpone the auction until it can remove all forecasted data center load from the auction and set up rules for a separate auction for data centers that do not provide for their own needs.
The December capacity market auction is for meeting reliability needs for a single “delivery year”—which is the year the costs are incurred—starting June 1, 2029, through May 31, 2030. The IMM has estimated that data centers already have driven up costs for the previous four capacity auctions by $29.4 billion—46 percent of the $63.6 billion in total capacity charges for the four years the auctions cover.
“Existing data centers and forecasted data center growth are driving up Maryland customer bills,” People’s Counsel David S. Lapp said. “It is common sense that ordinary households should not be paying billions in added costs for data centers, yet that is what is highly likely to happen if PJM proceeds with its December auction that includes a massive amount of forecasted data center electric demand growth. The auction must be delayed until PJM changes the rules to protect existing customers.”
The state consumer advocates ask the PJM Board to immediately direct PJM to request federal regulatory approval for postponing the December auction “until data center loads, both real and speculative, can be removed from the load forecast” and a separate auction for data centers proceeds.
PJM operates and plans the regional transmission system and runs power markets for Maryland, 12 other states and the District of Columbia.
Since summer 2024, OPC has been warning that PJM’s forecasts—which PJM uses to determine how much capacity it needs to procure—may substantially overstate forecasted data center demand causing billions in potential excess capacity costs. Since that time, utilities have walked back some of their projections, while other utilities have increased their projections. This past summer, Exelon reduced its earlier “high probability” forecast of data center growth by 11,000 megawatts, which is about the entire peak demand of the State of Maryland. PJM does not have—but should create—a uniform and transparent approach for its forecasts of data center growth, OPC has pointed out.
In addition to OPC, the consumer advocates joining the letter today include the Office of the Ohio Consumers’ Counsel, the Delaware Public Advocate, the Illinois Office of the Attorney General, the Illinois Citizens Utility Board, the New Jersey Division of Rate Counsel, the Pennsylvania Office of Consumer Advocate, and the West Virginia Consumer Advocate.
Visit OPC’s website to learn more about the costs and risks caused by data centers and OPC’s advocacy to protect residential customers.
The Maryland Office of People’s Counsel is an independent state agency that represents Maryland’s residential consumers in electric, natural gas, telecommunications, private water and certain transportation matters before the Public Service Commission, federal regulatory agencies, and the courts.
* * *
|