Showcasing the DNR: The best Father's Day gift

Share or view as webpage  |  Update preferences

- Showcasing the DNR -

A snapshot from May 1963 showing the author at 2 years old with his dad and a 19-inch brown trout.

The best Father's Day gift

"I've long since retired and my son's moved away. I called him up just the other day. I said, ‘I'd like to see you if you don't mind.’ He said, ‘I'd love to, dad, if I could find the time.’” - Sandy and Harry Chapin

By JOHN PEPIN
Michigan Department of Natural Resources

Having trouble figuring out what to give your dad for Father’s Day?  

There are all kinds of advertising, almost everywhere you look, offering hints for the best gift ideas for any dad.

Of course, there are neckties, initialed leather coasters, personalized golf balls, a mixed nut tray or a revolving wood organizer for “Dad’s stuff.”

You can even buy the powder blue “#1 Dad” T-shirt made famous in an episode of “Seinfeld” — the one where a white-haired Lloyd Bridges, playing an 80-year-old fitness trainer, looks at the undersized T-shirt Jerry’s dad is wearing and asks: “What the hell is that? …You think you are the number one dad?”

Jerry’s dad replies, boasting, “This was a gift from my son.”

A couple of years ago, Cosmopolitan compiled a list of “30 Gifts Your Dad Will Totally Love,” suggesting that “For once, you won't be forced to go halfsies with your sibling on a 12-pack of socks because you couldn't find anything better. Not again. Not this year!”

Those Cosmopolitan gift ideas ranged from “nice pants,” a portable charcoal grill or a fancy shaving kit to a leather jacket, a soft briefcase or a $550 pair of “cool shades.”

The author's dad, Phillip Pepin, on his mail route in Ishpeming in the 1970s.

Field and Stream was among those putting together lists geared specifically toward the dad who is an outdoorsman. 

Some of the gift ideas from those lists included whiskey or coffee, lanterns, knives and shirts or an insulated “thermal cloak,” which Field and Stream described as “essentially a hooded camo bag — helps keep a hunter warm, comfortable and concealed while sitting on a stand on cold, wet days.” You really should see the picture.

Then there are fishing rods, coffee mugs and beer steins, chocolate-covered potato chips, beef jerky and other snacks, a compass or fingernail clippers.

Over the years, since its creation in the early 20th Century, Father’s Day has not always been the most popular day with dads.

“Many men, however, continued to disdain the day,” according to history.com. “As one historian writes, they ‘scoffed at the holiday’s sentimental attempts to domesticate manliness with flowers and gift-giving, or they derided the proliferation of such holidays as a commercial gimmick to sell more products – often paid for by the father himself.’”

Washington state celebrated the first statewide Father’s Day in June 1910, fashioned after the increasingly popular Mother’s Day observance developed in the years following the Civil War.

Father’s Day was eventually made a nationwide holiday during the Nixon administration in 1972.

A ticket stub from a Harry Chapin concert attended by the author at the Carlton West Theatre in Green Bay, Wis.

One of the Cosmopolitan gift list ideas was a smart-looking men’s watch.

Admiring the attractive gold band, sharp hands and maker’s mark in the photograph, it occurred to me that truly the best gift you could give your dad for Father’s Day was not a watch, or any of these other things, but rather time itself.

In 1973, Harry Chapin recorded what Rolling Stone readers voted as fourth on the list of “All-time Saddest Songs.” “Cat’s in the Cradle,” released the following year, was a Billboard No. 1 hit single within two months.

Creation of the song began as a poem written by Chapin’s wife, Sandra. The couple had two children together and three from Sandy’s previous marriage adopted by Harry.

The song lyric detailed the shared time hoped for, but not realized, between a father and a son throughout their lives — from when the son is a boy looking up to his too-busy dad, until the father is retired and his son is a man, with kids of his own, now too busy himself.

“And the cat's in the cradle and the silver spoon, little boy blue and the man in the moon. When you coming home, dad? I don't know when, but we'll get together then,

You know we'll have a good time then,” Chapin wrote.

A seemingly widespread human failing seems to be the mistaken notion that there will always be more time beyond today to do the things we want to do.

We’ll take that trip, walk that road, climb that hill, fish that creek, hunt that valley, come back here next year and do the whole thing all over again.

The last time this group, representing three generations of the Pepin family, was together before Phillip Pepin died in 2008.

Maybe. And, if life steps in with an illness or a new job in another state or some other interruption, maybe not. 

In the 1970s, Harry Chapin used to come to Marquette and perform at Northern Michigan University. He and his band members would play basketball with some of the NMU team before his Hedgecock Fieldhouse show.

In 1981, Chapin was killed in a car accident on the Long Island Expressway. He was 38 years old when he died. The singer of that hit song about kids and dads never lived long enough to see his own children grown.

Death loves irony.

Those of us who have lost a dad or other loved one have learned, often painfully and after the fact, that there isn’t necessarily going to be a next time.

My dad died 11 years ago. In some years, his birthday falls on Father’s Day. This year, he would have been 93.

I wish every day we still had even one more minute to spend together, but we don’t.

As a father of two boys myself, who have now become accomplished men living in other states, I think a father could imagine no greater gift for himself than spending time with his son or daughter on Father’s Day — no matter what we decided to do, even just a silent walk in the woods or to only sit and talk.

When you come right down to it, a simple opportunity like that is worth more than a mountain of mixed nuts, all the personalized golf balls in Scotland or a king’s ransom worth of expensive slacks — it’s worth the world.

Check out previous Showcasing the DNR stories in our archive at Michigan.gov/DNRStories. To subscribe to upcoming Showcasing articles, sign up for free email delivery at Michigan.gov/DNR.


/Note to editors: Contact: John Pepin, Showcasing the DNR series editor, 906-226-1352. Accompanying photos and a text-only version of this story are available below for download. Caption information follows. Credit Michigan Department of Natural Resources, unless otherwise noted.

Text-only version of this story.

Group 1: Three generations of the Pepin family pose for a photograph after taking in a baseball game at Hurley Field in Marquette. From left, Jeff, John, Phillip and James Pepin.

Group 2: The last time this group, representing three generations of the Pepin family, was together before Phillip Pepin died in 2008. From left, Phillip, Jeff, John and James Pepin. The photo was taken in July 2005 in the backyard of the family home in Ishpeming.

Mailman: A photo showing Phillip Pepin, the author’s dad, on his mail route in Ishpeming in the 1970s.

Stub: A ticket stub from a Harry Chapin concert attended by the author at the Carlton West Theatre in Green Bay, Wis. in January 1981. Chapin, a singer-songwriter and father, died six months later in a car accident.

Trout: A snapshot from May 1963 showing the author at 2 years old with his dad and a 19-inch brown trout in his grandma’s kitchen in Palmer./

Was this email useful?