Council sets out next steps for Newton Abbot Market HallĀ



Frequently Asked Questions
The Council began procurement for a market operator in October 2025. The intention was to identify an operator in advance of opening so they could help shape aspects of the final fit out to ensure the building was fit for their vision. This is common practice with projects of this nature. The final due diligence began taking place prior to completion of the building in late spring 2026.
What exactly are the concerns that came up in due diligence?
As part of the process, the Council undertook comprehensive due diligence and detailed discussions with the prospective operator.
The Council is not discussing the detail of commercially confidential conversations. However, we have a responsibility to satisfy ourselves that any future operating arrangements provide a secure and sustainable long-term future for the Market Hall. Following that process, the Council concluded that further consideration is needed before a final decision is made.
Was the issue to do with the bidder's finances?
We are not discussing commercially confidential details of the due diligence process. What we can say is that the Council has a responsibility to satisfy itself that any operating arrangements provide a secure and sustainable long-term future for the Market Hall. At this stage, we concluded further consideration was required before a final decision could be made.
When did these concerns become apparent?
The issues emerged through the detailed due diligence and negotiation process as proposals were refined and assessed.
Due diligence is specifically designed to identify and test matters of this nature before any final agreement is entered into.
Why weren't they identified earlier in the process?
The procurement process and due diligence process serve different purposes.
Procurement assesses bidders against published criteria and identifies a preferred bidder. Following that, detailed due diligence and commercial discussions take place to test the practical arrangements required before a final agreement can be completed.
The concerns arose through that later stage of detailed assessment, which is exactly what the due diligence process is intended to do.
How did the council get this far before identifying concerns?
Appointing a preferred bidder is not the same as entering into a final agreement.
The Council deliberately carried out detailed due diligence before committing to long-term arrangements. That work identified issues that required further consideration and the Council has acted prudently by reviewing its options before making a final decision.
What does this mean for market traders?
The Council remains committed to delivering a vibrant and successful Market Hall that supports traders, businesses and visitors.
The current review relates to future operating arrangements and is intended to ensure the Market Hall is established on a sustainable footing. Existing traders will continue to be kept informed as significant decisions are made.
Will this increase rents?
No decisions have been made regarding future rents.
Any future operating arrangements would need to create a viable and sustainable Market Hall while also supporting traders and attracting a diverse range of businesses.
Why have they not been kept informed?
The Council has shared information where it has been appropriate and possible to do so.
Many aspects of the discussions involve commercially sensitive matters and it would not have been appropriate to provide updates while negotiations and due diligence were ongoing. We recognise traders are keen for certainty and will provide further updates as decisions are made.
Did the bidder withdraw or did the Council lose confidence in the proposal?
The bidder has not withdrawn and discussions remain ongoing.
The Council has also not ruled out working with the prospective operator. However, after completing its due diligence process, the Council concluded that it could not yet be fully satisfied that the proposed arrangements would provide a secure long-term future for the Market Hall. As a result, it is reviewing all available options before making a final decision.
How long will this review add to the delay in opening?
It is too early to put a precise timescale on the review.
The Council is seeking specialist industry advice and exploring all available options. The aim is to identify the quickest route to opening the Market Hall while ensuring it has the strongest possible foundations for long-term success.
When does the council now expect the market to open?
No opening date has been confirmed.
The Council understands the frustration caused by the delay and remains focused on bringing the Market Hall into use as soon as possible. The current review is intended to help achieve that by ensuring the right operating arrangements are in place.
What are the remaining fit out works?
The remaining works relate to the internal fit-out needed to prepare the building for occupation and operation.
The precise scope is still being reviewed, but the works would help ensure the Market Hall is ready for an operator to move in and begin trading as quickly as possible.
Why were they not completed earlier?
The original intention was for the future operator to help shape aspects of the fit-out so the building reflected their operational requirements.
The Council is now considering whether completing the remaining works in advance could help reduce delays and make the building more attractive and accessible to future operators.
Will the Council be liable for any additional spending?
No decisions on further expenditure have been made.
Any proposal would be subject to the Council's normal governance, financial and decision-making processes. The current proposal under consideration would utilise funding already allocated to the project rather than requiring additional external funding.
What are the 'other options' the council is exploring?
All available options remain under consideration.
These include continuing discussions with the current prospective operator, considering alternative operating models, reviewing the timing and scope of fit-out works, and taking specialist advice on the most effective approach to securing a sustainable long-term future for the Market Hall.
How much money/time has been spent pursuing negotiations with this bidder?
The Council does not regard the work undertaken as wasted.
Detailed due diligence and commercial discussions are an important part of any significant project and are designed to identify risks and test proposals before long-term commitments are entered into. This process has helped inform the Council's decision-making and ensure public money is protected.
When will the council make a final decision on an operator?
The Council wants to ensure it fully understands all available options and receives specialist advice before determining the best way forward. An update will be provided once that work has been completed.
Is the council likely to run the market themselves?
No decision has been made and all options remain under consideration.
The Council's priority is to secure a successful and sustainable future for the Market Hall. Specialist advice is being sought and any future operating model will be assessed against that objective before a decision is made.